The hunt is over! Thanks so much for solving! Solutions are available for all puzzles. A wrap-up post will be coming in around a week late January.

MerryFinnmas

Solves

Total: 26

Toggle spoiler tags for secret content:
Puzzle Solve Time
Divining the Elements
Antarctic Hold'em
Meta on the Dancefloor
21 Magic Is in the Air
24 Why Is My Verse So Barren and So Flat?
23 Fish Are Food, Not Friends
18 Off the Beaten Path
22 Higher State of Mind
19 Those Crafty Penguins
20 Go Fish
17 Sack of Gifts
6 September of the Puffins
9 Overt Infiltration
14 Ice Pack
16 Tidying Up
15 Migratory Birds
13 The Arcade
11 Check It Out!
7 Spy Games
10 Flipping Channels
8 Survival Stories
4 Subnivean Snake
5 1. e4 e5
3 Double-Crossed
2 Metrology Lab
1 Penguin Pidgin